navigating
the economy
Design Co-Op Coalesces Collaboration, Education,
and Practice
Architects band together to boost their skill sets and find new opportunities
by Tracy Ostroff
Contributing Editor
How do you .
. . group
together during difficult economic times to share clients, projects,
and expertise?
Summary: Hyperform
Design Co-op is a Colorado nonprofit corporation that provides educational
and collaborative opportunities to designers and small design firms.
The organizational model allows members of the co-op to work individually
as designers or use the professional resources of the group for projects.
Membership is open to all designers and design professionals.
At its weekly meetings, the group discusses ongoing projects, potential leads for new work, research-based pursuits, and educational opportunities in an open and collaborative environment.
The co-op is the brainchild of Tim Geisler, AIA, LEED-AP, who reached
out to Eric Anderson, AIA, a long-term friend and colleague, to take
on the role of co-director of the 501(c)(3) organization, based in
Arvada, Colo. Geisler and some out-of-work colleagues began meeting
informally in his home to collaborate on theoretical and urban design
projects, share resources, and discuss the state of the profession
and the economy in a safe forum, he explains.
The group, now at about 15 members, mostly in Colorado but also
from California, Mexico, and China, grew by word of mouth and personal
associations, as well as through the “Architect” group
on LinkedIn. At first it was an ad-hoc group with no revenue or expenses.
But with potential clients who were interested in hiring the co-op,
Geisler says it was imperative to incorporate. “As soon as
there came to be fees and revenue involved, we were obliged to incorporate
if we wanted to move forward with some of this work, like a project
for a church in Texas.” The group meets weekly in Geisler’s
office at a Jehn Engineering building in Arvada, where he also maintains
a street gallery presence to exhibit work and keep the office fresh.
“I knew in my gut that it was possible to do work for clients
as a nonprofit. It was just a matter of setting it up.” It
was also a matter of timing with the economy. “It turns out
that clients these days, when they don’t have a lot of money,
like the feeling of an organization with little overhead and competent
managers.”
New working model
Geisler’s office, Hyperform LLC, now serves
as the co-op headquarters. Each member entity maintains its own office,
and the relationship of Geisler’s design practice to the co-op
is the same as any other member. The group, Geisler says, is formed
on a number of mutual understandings. “First, we understand
that the co-op is not for profit, and the co-op does not distribute
revenue to its members or directors or anyone else. The second understanding
we have is that the co-op is an open forum, and we agree not to use
information that we learn in the meetings to steal clients. There
is a no-compete agreement, so we can openly share information and
not worry much about it. And a third is that we understand what the
mission of the co-op is: to provide educational and collaborative
opportunities to designers.”
The members’ only responsibility is to contribute to the intellectual
life of the group. There is no expectation that a member bring work
to the co-op, and all souls need not be bared. “If I have a
project I can do myself, and I just want to plow forward with it
and not even discuss it with the co-op, I am free to do that, and
all the other member companies are free to do the same thing. But,
when something comes up, so far, the people who have joined the co-op
are people I know or know of, or people who know people who joined
early on. There isn’t a whole lot of work, but what I do get,
generally speaking, it just feels right to share it.”
From left to right, Carrie Momeni, marketing director, and members Cindy Leibman, Steve Wagley, Amy Burke, Tim Nuanes, Dan Gonzales, Eric Anderson, AIA, and Tim Geisler, AIA.
Market advantages
When they started meeting in October, they had
only one paid project—a
solar architectural feature for a client in Cheyenne, Wyo. Geisler
just received word that the co-op was designated by the State of
Colorado as a pre-qualified provider of as-needed architectural services. “We
are really excited about this, as it is our first open RFQ that has
resulted in an awarded contract.”
The rest of their time, Geisler says, is spent on theoretical and
speculative architectural design work, as well as on critiquing portfolios,
and possible entries for design entries. But still, part of the reason
for having weekly meetings, Geisler says, and getting together with
each other and working on speculative work or competitions is to
explore each others’ skill sets, so we can really match our
abilities up with the requirements of a particular project.”
From time to time, when there is work, and they need support from
an individual or from the co-op as a group, they can find it from
within their cohorts. “So far, we have had a couple of members
who have had access to some work, which they either aren’t
big enough to do themselves or are not licensed architects, so they
will look to one of the directors to help them out or check and stamp
drawings, if necessary, or to another member to provide the skill
set the client needs.”
Market advantages of working through the co-op, Geisler adds, also
include access to experienced AIA members; easy, risk-free access
to multi-disciplinary input; use of standardized procedural forms;
and the ability to build working relationships that could evolve
into partnerships or employment.
Geisler points to a project in China as an example of sharing work
in the co-op. “I have a background in China and have done some
consulting work over there, but have not worked on a specific project.
A colleague of mine there needed a landscape architect, and I passed
that along to one of our members, a landscape architect who teaches
at the University of Colorado in Denver. Now she and some colleagues
are doing this, and I’m providing client management and contract
management.”
“We do everything we can to make each member succeed, providing guidance on everything from client communication to budgeting to IDP assistance and sponsorship,” Geisler says of the group he founded with co-director Eric Anderson.
Marketing
The members market individually, and as the co-op. At 30-minute
weekly meetings that far-flung members can attend via Web conferencing
software, they discuss potential leads, including requests for proposals.
At a recent meeting, they discussed setting up a file-sharing service.
So far, they have collaborated on design projects in Texas, Wyoming,
Colorado, and China. In most cases, one member is the primary contract
holder. Group member Amy Burke, a designer in Colorado, appreciates
the opportunity to turn to the group as a place to pool resources.
She can rely upon the organization as a way to bolster her own position
as a sole proprietor in the marketplace. “You can go after
a project and know that you could bring it into the co-op and have
these resources who could fill in their specialties [or, if the project
goes beyond a member’s expertise,] hand it off to people you
know and trust.
“It’s an interesting opportunity in a market when you
don’t want to build an office with employees and assistants,” Anderson
says. He sees the co-op as an entity that can be used to function
as a larger office as needed. He also sees the co-op as poised to
pick up on the trends of architectural practice, particularly in
sustainable design and alternative energy. He’s encouraged
by stimulus funds trickling down to the states and by the change
of leadership in Washington that is focusing more on new technologies.
The co-op is providing educational opportunities in these areas and
investigating opportunities with solar energy companies.
Different working model
“We have found that there is a lot
of good will out there. We promote a spirit of mentorship and collaboration
in a profession that sometimes appears to engender a culture of domination
and territorialism,” Geisler
says. The group is looking to reach out to the related fields, including
interior design, landscape architecture, and urban planning, to become
a more well-rounded organization, Anderson notes.
Cindy Leibman, a designer in Denver, just joined the co-op in the
past couple of weeks, having been laid off from her firm four months
ago. She characterizes the group as “collaborative and welcoming.” She
liked the group’s commitment to pro bono work, which she had
been doing on her own since losing her job. For example, the co-op
is working with agencies in the city of Arvada and the board of directors
of Historic Olde Town Arvada to enhance vacant storefronts.
Geisler thinks this model can stick beyond the current recession. “It
is something that happened without a lot of intentionality, but as
it turns out it addressed a couple of the criticisms that I have
had of current architectural practice, which is that so many architectural
practices, and not all by any means, but many cultivate a culture
of domination and territorialism … I have always thought that
it would be great and I would thrive in a organization that focuses
more on mentorship and collaboration. A lot of architects feel that
way and are struggling to find that really healthy work environment.
I hope that this will be one way to get there.” |