Points of View
REVIEW: Patterns of Home: The Ten Essentials of Enduring Design
by Max Jacobson, AIA; Murray Silverstein, AIA; and Barbara Winslow, AIA, (Taunton Press, 2002)
reviewed by
Stephanie Stubbs, Assoc. AIA
Managing Editor

Stepped rock walls help this house by Lake/Flato Architects "Inhabit the Site."Back in school, we were absolutely awed by Christopher Alexander's A Pattern Language; so much so that we spent days traipsing around our converted warehouse of a school and its surround searching for evidence of "patterns." With more than 200 patterns at our disposal, even we students had no trouble finding them. The reason for the immense appeal is that the patterns were Truth—they were architecture theory in the flesh for us. They also offered a way to crack the code, to pull single threads out of the complicated tapestry of what we were trying so hard to figure out: how you design firm, commodious, and delightful buildings.

Architect George Homsey designed this space to allow people to both sit around the fire and enjoy the view, "Capturing the Light" both at eye level and above.It is perhaps even more difficult to convey the interwoven complexity of design to clients than to architecture students. Three architects—Max Jacobson, AIA; Murray Silverstein, AIA; and Barbara Winslow, AIA—have given us a useful tool to help convey the magic: it's a book called Patterns of Home: The Ten Essentials of Enduring Design. The authors, two of whom worked on the original pattern language with Alexander at the Center for Environmental Architecture in Berkeley, and all of whom are principals at JSW Architects, offer 10 "patterns of home," complex rules that designers employ—often intuitively—to design great houses. Following the intent of the original Pattern Language, the patterns of home allow clients and interested laypeople to understand (and articulate!) what resonates in a residence for them.

This trellis filters light into the attached living room of this house designed by Cass Calder Smith Architecture, thus contributing to "Creating Rooms, Outside and In."Ten essential patterns
1. Inhabiting the Site. This pattern embodies thinking of the house and site not only as a singular entity, but also a part of a larger whole. "Get it right," the authors say, "and the rest of the design flows smoothly."
2. Creating Rooms, Outside and In. Looking at the site as a "mosaic of rooms, some inside, some out." Outdoor rooms should be as clearly defined and invested with purpose as the inside rooms.
3. Sheltering Roof. "The overall roof plan, how it orients and shapes the spaces below and around it, how the parts of the roof are linked, the details of roof construction, and how they will be expressed inside and out . . . all fit the pattern of Sheltering Roof."
4. Capturing Light. A house must be open to the light and warmth of the sun, the authors tell us. And important rooms must have light from at least two sides.
5. Parts in Proportion. A balanced whole is composed of parts (which in turn are composed of parts themselves) that are in balance and scale with each other and the whole itself.
6. The Flow-through Rooms. Proper flow begins with arriving on the site, how we enter, where we pause, and how we navigate and move through the rooms themselves.
Check out the geometry and the rhythm of the ground and wall elements that frame this house and site by Eric Haesloop, and demonstrate the harmony of "parts in proportion."7. Private Edges, Common Core. A good home balances private (some for everyone!) and communal space and supports these functions through appropriate lighting, circulation, and room and roof shape.
8. Refuge and Outlook. "One of the abiding pleasures that homes offer is being in and looking out," the authors write, "providing a solid, stable, and protected place from which you can look out toward and over a larger 'beyond.'"
9. Places in Between. This pattern celebrates those favored areas that are both outside and in: porches, bay window seat and beds, breezeways, gazebos.
10. Composing with Materials. "Compose materials as a melody—those that support and underscore; those that offer counterpoint, slow the procession—all with a view to letting the building sing."

A bed nook in the roof of a house designed by Jim Givens offers a "Private Edge" that "Captures Light" and expertly employs a "Sheltering Roof."Well-crafted, details and whole
Patterns of Home is as well crafted as its theory. As you probably can tell from some of the statements above, the book is beautifully written, providing thoughtful and almost poetic descriptions of the case-study houses and their patterns under discussion. David Livingston's beautiful photos of these exemplary houses are generously sized—many are full-page—and accompanied by explanatory sketches and diagrams.

The interior of the house by Haesloop, showing equally beautiful proportions in the interior.The authors fortify the building case studies with boxed discussions of "Patterns in Context," which explains how several of the patterns are used in that particular building, and tips of "Working with the Pattern." Tips presented under "Working with the Pattern" of "Parts in Proportion" advise us to "organize the house along lines of movement and growth" and "let the overall form of the house grow naturally out of the forms of its various parts, rather than being superimposed from outside. In this sense, the form of the house equals the form of its parts." When a pattern is in evidence in a chapter other than its own (e.g., when "Light" shows up in the "Flow-through Rooms" chapter), it is called out in the text in a highlighted font. The integration of the patterns becomes apparent.

Patterns of Home would offer a fascinating introduction to clients on how design integration creates residential magic that just "feels right" in a home. They could begin to understand what they are liking and why they are liking it. Anyone who looks at this book, however, will not be able to discount its tremendous appeal for designers and architects. It's integrated work and fun—do you see a pattern here?

Copyright 2002 The American Institute of Architects. All rights reserved.

 
Reference

The holiday season is just around the corner—and this book would be a great gift! Order it from the AIA Bookstore, $31.50 AIA members/$34.95 retail (plus $6 shipping); phone 800-242-3837 option #4, fax 202-626-7519, or send an email.

Photos by David Livingston

Refer this article to a friend by email.Go back to AIArchitect.comEmail your comments to the author.Email your comments to the editor.